Photo Credit: Nick Turchario-USA TODAY Sports

Cleveland is listening to trade offers for Edwin Encarnacion

It looks like Cleveland is going into some kind of re-tool operation as their core hasn’t been able to get over the hump since reaching the World Series in 2016. Cleveland is shopping two of their top pitchers, Corey Kluber and Trevor Bauer, and they’re also reportedly listening to offers on former Blue Jay Edwin Encarnacion.

Chris Antonetti, director of baseball operations, touched on the different paths the Indians are considering taking to remain dominant in the AL Central and create payroll flexibility when he said, “We’re focused on the two goals: we want to make sure we have a team that’s capable of winning the American League Central in 2019 and then also better position our team for success beyond that. There are a variety of different ways that can happen with a variety of different impacts on our payroll. What those opportunities will be for us over the next coming weeks to execute on those goals, I don’t know for certain. But we’ll actively explore them.”

To me, this sounds like Cleveland is aware of just how bad the American League Central is and they’re trying to slash payroll while being still good enough to walk to another division banner. They have a whole bunch of free agents in the next few years, including the aforementioned Bauer, Kluber, and Encarnacion, and stars like Francisco Lindor and Jose Ramirez are going to be due for big raises.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

It makes sense that Cleveland, a small-market, low-budget team (yes, this is because of ownership and not exclusively because of Mark Shapiro, despite what many here would tell you) would look to do a mini teardown and retool for later on rather than letting all of their impending free agents walk away for nothing.

As we know, Edwin ended up in Cleveland after a disastrous situation with Toronto. The Jays reportedly offered Edwin $80 million over four years, Edwin declined and wanted to weigh his options, the Jays quickly turned around and signed Kendrys Morales to a cheaper three-year deal, and Edwin ended up taking less money to sign in Cleveland because his market evaporated. While the dip from Edwin to Kendrys was a big one, Toronto did end up with a compensation pick that they used on Nate Pearson for him leaving in free agency.

Should the Jays be interested in bringing Edwin home?

Edwin is going to be 36 years old at the beginning of next season. He clubbed 32 bombs last year but posted an .810 OPS which was his worst since before his breakout season with the Jays in 2012. He’s signed for $21,667,000 in 2019 as his dead was backloaded, and he has a $20,000,000 team option for 2020 with a $5,000,000 buyout.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

I wonder if something can be done involving him and Morales. Kendrys would give Cleveland a DH-platoon option who’s much cheaper than Edwin is for 2019 and it would eliminate the buyout for them in 2020. Cleveland needs bullpen help, so maybe they can throw in some arms to sweeten the deal. That way we can watch Edwin smack career-homer No. 400 in Toronto next year, which would be fucking awesome.

I mean, there isn’t much sense to a trade involving Toronto and Cleveland and Edwin and Kendrys other than sentimental value and the fact it would be hilarious if those two were traded for each other so one team could save money.

      • The Humungus

        I mean, they signed a 33 year old DH to a back-loaded contract and are looking at trading from their outstanding starting rotation despite having two absolute stud position players providing insane amounts of surplus value.

    • Nice Guy Eddie

      This is s joke, right? The Indians want to dump EE’s salary. He’s an expensive old player in decline. Why would they take the same salary back in two players and give away a prospect for the ‘privilege’? The Indians are more likely to trade Encarnacion for Morales straight up to save the money on two similar players, but they’re not going to take Pillar and they’re not going to trade a valuable prospect. And Toronto would be stupid to trade Morales for EE just to eat the extra money. Be thankful EE turned down the offer and move on.

      • Nice Guy Eddie

        Actually, I’m going to walk this back a little bit. I didn’t include the extra 6.7M that EE is owed. Wow! That really is a mess for the Indians. I don’t think they’ll be “listening to trade offers for Edwin Encarnacion” unless you count the sound of crickets as trade offers. I’ll walk back what I said. I didn’t give the proposed deal proper thought. To get out from under that $26.7M mess they just might do something along those lines, though likely not with Tristan.

  • The Sausage King of Chicago

    26 million (including the buyout) to come home, get his 400th HR while witnessing how much he’s declined since 2016?
    Don’t get me wrong, I love Edwin. But what’s the point?
    I’m honestly not trying to be negative, but my fear of this would be similar to JBats’ last season with the Jays. Sure, it was awesome giving him a send off the final home series, but it was painful to watch him play for that entire season.

  • Regulator Johnson

    Given that the opportunity cost of $15 million this year is nil I’d gladly make an Edwin for Kendrys swap.

    Tough to imagine the Jays being a fit for him though – the Indians probably don’t have any interest in Morales and it just doesn’t make sense for the Jays to throw money at Edwin at this stage in their team development.

    Astros seem to make the most sense: they are trying to win it all, have no one in the DH slot & the team is young enough that they shouldn’t need to keep it vacant. One year of Edwin @ 26 is probably a worthier gamble for them than it is for us, sad as that is to admit.