The Blue Jays couldn’t capitalize despite having two of the best pitchers in 2026

The Blue Jays couldn’t capitalize despite having two of the best pitchers in 2026
Photo credit: © Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images
Kylie Tait
Nov 16, 2026, 12:49 EST
Dylan Cease and Louis Varland were two of the best pitchers in baseball in 2026.
On Wednesday, Cease and Varland were named to the All-MLB First Team. Varland also earned BBWAA American League Reliever of the Year, while Cease finished second in AL Cy Young voting.
In his first year with the Toronto Blue Jays, Cease posted a 2.40 ERA across 29 starts. His 239 strikeouts were a career high and the third-most in MLB. Cease’s highlights included carrying a no-hitter into the ninth inning against the San Francisco Giants and pitching a complete-game shutout against the Boston Red Sox. The Blue Jays really couldn’t have asked for more from Cease in his first year with the team.
Varland stepped into the closer role for the Blue Jays in April after a tumultuous start to the season from Jeff Hoffman. To say he filled the role well would be an understatement. He was perfect in his first 24 save opportunities and finished the season with 35 saves in 37 opportunities. His 1.27 ERA was the lowest among MLB relievers.
Spencer Miles and Tyler Rogers each also received votes for Reliever of the Year.
The recognition is well-deserved for both Cease and Varland. However, it also emphasizes how much the offence let the Blue Jays down in 2026.
Aside from Cease, the only other pitchers from non-playoff teams who received AL Cy Young votes were Reid Detmers of the Los Angeles Angels and Michael Wacha of the Kansas City Royals. Similarly, for Reliever of the Year, Jacob Latz and Garrett Whitlock of the Texas Rangers were the only other players from non-playoff teams to receive votes aside from Varland, Miles, and Rogers.
Individual awards aren’t necessarily an indicator of a team’s success, but they do show that the Blue Jays had the pieces to be far more competitive than they were in 2026. Two players can’t carry a team to the postseason, but it’s pretty disappointing for a team to finish 79-83 with one of the best starters and the best reliever in the AL.
The Blue Jays ranked 17th in batting fWAR (19.0). They had the fewest home runs (152), the fewest RBIs (615), the second-worst walk rate (7.6 per cent), the fifth-worst slugging percentage (.381) and the sixth-worst on-base percentage (.310).
The numbers are already bad, but they look even worse compared to 2025, when the Blue Jays had one of the best offences in MLB. They were first in OBP (.333), second in batting fWAR (32.6), third in RBIs (771), seventh in slugging, (.427), and 13th in home runs (191) and walk rate (8.4 per cent).
The Blue Jays’ offensive falloff meant that they weren’t able to capitalize on having two of the best pitchers in MLB.
Poor offence was not the only reason why the Blue Jays had a disappointing season in 2026. The team battled injuries throughout the season, which meant several key players missed significant time. That made the season an uphill battle before factoring in poor performance.
However, in a particularly weak year across the American League, the Blue Jays had all the tools to make the postseason, despite the injuries.
The starting rotation was the most affected by the injury bug in 2026. That put extra pressure on the bullpen to help the Blue Jays get by. Despite the difficult circumstances, Blue Jays pitchers actually performed better in 2026 than in 2025. The Blue Jays’ ERA improved from 4.19 in 2025 to 3.91 in 2026. They also improved from 11.3 fWAR in 2025 to 16.2 in 2026.
A lot of that improvement is due to Cease (5.5) and Varland (3.1), who finished with the highest fWAR on the Blue Jays in 2026. However, pitchers such as Miles, Rogers, Braydon Fisher, and Mason Fluharty also played a significant role in the Blue Jays’ improved pitching.
But despite allowing fewer runs in 2026 (721 vs. 694), the Blue Jays were far less competitive. A big reason for that is that they scored 150 fewer runs than in 2025 (798 vs. 694). For all the improvements from the pitching, despite being hampered by injuries, it didn’t make a difference because the offence failed to hold up its end of the bargain.
The good news for the Blue Jays is that they have a lot of strong players heading into 2027. If Cease and Varland perform anywhere close to how they did in 2026, those are great pieces to build the pitching staff around.
Plus, the offence is a lot stronger than what it showed in 2026. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. easily had the worst season of his career; Alejandro Kirk missed two months with a fractured thumb; and Addison Barger only played nine games. The Blue Jays are in the market for a big bat during the offseason, which will help with some of the offensive woes. However, there is power in the Blue Jays’ roster; they just need to show it. Being healthy enough to play is a great place to start.
A lot went wrong for the Blue Jays in 2026, but Cease and Varland were easily the two biggest bright spots. Despite the injuries the Blue Jays dealt with, the team missed a huge opportunity to capitalize on having two of the best pitchers in MLB.

PRESENTED BY THE PERFECT 9 COLLECTION

Some baseball traditions never get old. The Perfect 9 Collection is our newest limited-edition collaboration with Blue Jays Today, inspired by the viral 9/9/9 challenge that has become a staple of baseball culture. Whether you’re taking on the challenge or just enjoying a day at the ballpark, this collection celebrates the moments that make baseball unforgettable. Featuring premium Levelwear apparel with elevated fabrics and modern fits, it’s designed for fans who live and breathe the game—on game day and beyond. Limited edition. Premium quality. Built for baseball fans. Shop the Perfect 9 Collection while it lasts. Exclusively at nationgear.ca