logo
Instant Reaction: Alejandro Kirk leaves with injury as Blue Jays are walked off by White Sox
alt
Photo credit: © Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images
Ryley Delaney
Apr 3, 2026, 17:15 EDTUpdated: Apr 3, 2026, 17:36 EDT
Comments
The Toronto Blue Jays’ struggles against subpar opponents has continued.
On Friday afternoon, the Blue Jays dropped a 5-4 extra innings decision to the Chicago White Sox. Once again, their offence looked lethargic through the majority of the game, as Sean Burke shut them down. Let’s take a look at what went on in this one.
The White Sox started off the game with an opener, with Grant Taylor throwing just nine pitches, all strikes, to get the Jays in order. Dylan Cease struggled with command in the first inning, walking the first batter he faced, allowing a hit from Munetaka Murakami, before committing a fielding error for the White Sox’s first run.
Sean Burke took over for Taylor in the top of the second inning, giving up a double to Addison Barger, his first hit of the season. Barger was immediately driven in by Alejandro Kirk, as he doubled to his pull side for just his third hit of the season. Unfortunately, two strikeouts and a lineout left Kirk stranded.
Cease pitched a scoreless bottom of the second but the White Sox restored their lead in the bottom of the third. That inning started off well, as Cease struck out Murakami, but walked the next batter and gave up a hit to Colson Montgomery. The White Sox pulled off a double steal, allowing Austin Hays’ single to score both runs to make it 3-1.
The Blue Jays’ lethargic offence finally woke up in the top of the eighth. With Burke out of the game, Ernie Clement led off the inning with a single. Next up was Andrés Giménez, who took Jordan Leasure deep for his second home run of the season to tie the game at three.
This game went to extra innings, with the Blue Jays receiving a fortunate run in the top of the 10th. However, Kirk left the game injured, then Derek Hill laid down a bunt with two outs. Unfortunately, Tyler Heineman’s throw in front of the plate was yanked, bringing home the tying run. The next batter lined it over the infield for the win.

Takeaways…

The Blue Jays may be 4-3 to start the season, but this has been a horrendous start to the season. Over their last four, the Blue Jays are 1-3 against the Colorado Rockies and Chicago White Sox. Those are not games that they should be losing, even with a struggling offence.
It doesn’t help that it appears that the Blue Jays have suffered two key injuries. In the series opener against the Rockies, Cody Ponce went down with an ACL sprain and will be out for a while. In this game, Alejandro Kirk left the game after taking a foul off his thumb.
Dylan Cease’s scouting report throughout his career is that he is consistently inconsistent, which he showed on Friday afternoon. Following his incredible debut on Saturday where he struck out 12 over five and one-third innings, Cease pitched just four and one-third innings. The righty struck out six, but allowed three free passes and was tagged for three runs, two of which were earned.
That led to the Blue Jays turning to the bullpen sooner rather than later, which isn’t great given they have a bullpen day set for Saturday. Braydon Fisher struck out three over an inning and two thirds, Brendon Little struck out a batter in a perfect inning. Good to see him get back on track.
Louis Varland allowed a hit but struck out a batter to maintain his 0 ERA. Tyler Rogers allowed a lead-off hit in the bottom of the ninth, but stranded the runner on second. Jeff Hoffman looked sharp, but was the pitcher who took the loss. It should’ve been a save, as the Blue Jays had a string of insane bad luck.
Tyler Heineman should not have thrown the ball, he didn’t have a great angle on it. It’s hard to fault him too much, as it’s never easy to enter the game in the situation he did. Really, it’s just a series of very unfortunate events.
This was easily Kazuma Okamoto’s worst game of the season. He had shown a penchant for striking out in past games, including three in the Blue Jays’ victory over the Colorado Rockies, but Friday’s game was a different beast. All four of his plate appearances resulted in him whiffing to strike out. Over his 31 big league plate appearances, Okamoto has struck out 15 times for a 48.4 K%.
Okamoto accounted for four of the Blue Jays’ 11 strikeouts. Jesús Sánchez had his first tough game as a Blue Jays, striking out three times, which makes up 63.6% of the Blue Jays’ strikeouts in this game.
After Wednesday’s game, I noted that George Springer’s quality of at bats haven’t been terrific. That wasn’t the case in this one, hitting a single, drawing a walk, and not striking out. He also put the ball in the play scored the Jays’ fourth run. Addison Barger notched his first hit of the season, while Kirk’s double was just his third hit of the season.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has to get going at some point. Yes, he’s batting .292 and has a .452 on-base percentage, but all seven of his hits have been singles. You’ll take that from most batters, but not your superstar who is batting third.
What can the Blue Jays do other than erase this one from their memory and hope that Kirk’s injury isn’t a long-term thing. They have to find a way to win this series, and that begins with a game on Saturday afternoon with a 2:10 PM ET start time. It appears that it’ll be a bullpen game.
Ryley Delaney is a Nation Network writer for Blue Jays Nation, Oilersnation, and FlamesNation. She can be followed on Twitter @Ryley__Delaney.

Featured

News

Breaking News