Billy McKinney will return to New York. He’ll join the #BlueJays with Luke Maile going on the paternity list. The former Yankee injured his shoulder crashing into the wall at Rogers Centre.
The Billy McKinney era begins

Billy McKinney is being given a shot to show up his former team. The Blue Jays have recalled the outfielder acquired in the J.A. Happ trade to replace Luke Maile who was placed on the paternity list.
Since being acquired by the Jays a few weeks ago, McKinney has slashed a .203/.292/.453 line with the Buffalo Bisons over the course of 20 games.
It’s been a pretty ugly season for the former top-100 prospect. He started the season with the Yankees but got hurt in the team’s second game against the Jays at Rogers Centre. He hasn’t really found his footing in the minors since. All told, McKinney has slashed a .222/.307/.470 line for the season across multiple levels. It certainly isn’t bad, but it isn’t as good as what he did in 2017.
This stint probably won’t last long, but I imagine we’ll see quite a bit of McKinney in September when rosters expand. It seems he’s jumped over Dalton Pompey on the organization’s depth chart for outfielders, and he could well be ahead of Anthony Alford and Dwight Smith Jr. too.
Breaking News
- Blue Jays Nation’s 2026 Pre-Season Prospect Countdown – No. 11: Victor Arias
- The 2024 trade deadline moves are starting to pay dividends for the Blue Jays
- One stat to be excited about for every Blue Jays pitcher heading into 2026
- Instant Reaction: 2025 draftee Jake Casey hits late home run in Blue Jays’ 8-7 loss to Yankees
- Elbow surgery ‘is on the table’ for Blue Jays prospect Chay Yeager
