Talking great moments from Blue Jays and Jays Talk history with Mike Wilner

Wow, that’s a loaded question. There have been so many over the decades of watching this team. I would say it was Roy Howell’s walk-off homer in the bottom of the 9^th at the Ex in 1978 to beat the Twins, which I clearly remember being there to watch, but Baseball Reference says that never happened, so that can’t be it.

The Carter homer was magnificent, of course. I was watching in my living room after high-tailing it home from a waitering shift at the Pickle Barrel that night since I remembered being nearly crushed to death in the crowd at Yonge and Dundas the year before after watching the Game 6 win on the Jumbotron at the Dome.

I don’t remember reacting to the Alomar home run off Eckersley in the ’92 ALCS with a “this shows that we can beat them now!”, but it was absolutely a huge, huge hit both at the time and, quite obviously, in retrospect.

The batflip was amazing (though I was watching the ball, not Jose, so I didn’t see it in real time), and it’s the only one of the all-time great Blue Jays’ moments that I’ve actually witnessed in person. I was there for both cycles, Gruber’s and Frye’s, but those don’t stand up in the pantheon.

It has to be the Carter homer, doesn’t it? I know it wasn’t Game 7 and the series wasn’t on the line at that moment, but a walk off home run to win a World Series had only happened once before in history, and hasn’t happened since, and it was at the height of Blue Jays mania across the country. It was an incredible, incredible thing.

You’ve reminded me of a time that I ran around my basement pounding the walls in celebration of a Blue Jays’ moment, and it was the George Bell catch off Ron Hassey’s shallow fly to left that clinched the division in the penultimate game of 1985.

Alomar being anyone’s favourite Blue Jay shouldn’t necessarily be a nostalgia thing. He was an incredibly exciting player who hit for a high average, played phenomenal defence, stole bases, hit big home runs – he did so many things that got us up out of our seats on a seemingly regular basis. I think he’s a lot of people’s favourite Jay of all time.

For me it’s often difficult to separate the person from the player, since I’ve been covering the team in some fashion or another since 1988, which is why John McDonald keeps creeping into my head whenever someone asks me who my favourite Blue Jay is or was. He was the best defensive shortstop I’ve ever had a chance to see on a regular basis, the Fathers’ Day home run is something few people who were paying attention to the Blue Jays at the time will ever forget, and more than all of that, he is a really terrific human being.

Which is not to say that there haven’t been, or continue to be, many Blue Jays who are terrific human beings. Johnny Mac just stands out for me.

I have to say that it was pretty cool to go to my first game and meet U.L. Washington, who managed that team. He was the Kansas City Royals’ shortstop through their great run in the early ‘80s, though he had given way to Buddy Biancalana for the heartbreaking 1985 ALCS. And yes, he still had the toothpick.

I think the coolest story from that year – other than having to bail in the middle of the second game of a doubleheader at Bernie Arbor Stadium against the Hamilton Cardinals due to, ummm, gastrointestinal distress – was in a game in July or August when the light-hitting third baseman came out to the mound to pitch and started flipping up knuckleballs. We didn’t even know he was working on the pitch or that they were thinking of pitching him in a game. At the beginning, we didn’t even know what was going on. And two years later, Tim Wakefield was a Sid Bream slide away from being the NLCS MVP.

Also, I left my headlights on for a game against the Blue Jays at Community Park in St. Catharines and had to call the CAA. So I got to spend a couple of extra hours in a parking lot in your town.

Never

There have been a few. I mean, the greatest moments in BlueJaysTalk history were probably those two episodes of “Wednesdays With J.P.”, when then-GM J.P. Ricciardi said “it’s not a lie if we know the truth” and “did you know that Adam Dunn doesn’t really like baseball?” The first one was in response to a fan asking him why the Jays had said B.J. Ryan was held out of spring training games for a back issue and then had to have Tommy John surgery, the second was to a criticism of the Jays for not trying to trade for Dunn at the deadline, I think.

As far as the non-J.P. shows, a couple of them stand out to me. There was a caller who referred to himself as “The Baseball Genius” and then went on to say that the Jays should try to trade for “that Gino Gonzalez in Washington” and “the righty Mark Buehrle with the Cubs”. There was another pitcher he mentioned whose name or team or pitching arm he messed up, too. I’m pretty sure he was pulling my leg, but if nothing else he was funny, and definitely memorable. I’m not sure when that call was, but it had to be before 2013, before the Jays got Buehrle from the White Sox.

There was a call back in 2007, after a journeyman 30 year-old September call-up named Tike Redman had had a big series against the Jays for Baltimore. He was hitting .340 in minimal at-bats and someone called up and suggested the Jays trade Vernon Wells for him. This was during a down year for Vernon, but he was only 28, coming off an all-star season and three straight Gold Gloves. And before the Wells contract became such a topic of conversation. That was something.

I’m sure there are so many more that I can’t remember specifically. I need to hunker down with the old tapes – I guess digital files, now – and write a book someday.

Indescribable. And yes, extremely surreal. There are lots of times when I’m sitting there in the booth before a game, and often even during a game, and I think to myself: “This is what I do for a living. This is nuts.” It’s unreal. And to think that I could be to some kid what Tom and Jerry were to me growing up completely blows my mind.

Definitely. I’ve compared this current team to the 1982 Jays more than a few times. They were right on the cusp of being really, really good for a really long time. About to embark on a run of 11 straight winning seasons, all of which would have put them in the playoffs under the current system, I believe.

That ’82 team had Dave Stieb in his first full season (1981 doesn’t count because of the two-month strike), Willie Upshaw, Damaso Garcia, Lloyd Moseby and Jesse Barfield were full-time players all 25 and younger, George Bell and Tony Fernandez were in the minors, on the cusp of coming up, and it was the first time that the Jays didn’t finish alone in last place in the division. There are lots of parallels, I think. Now, are these guys going to wind up being as good as those guys were? Only time will tell, but the talent in the 25-and-under players who are already here like Danny Jansen, Rowdy Tellez, Lourdes Gurriel, Jr., Teoscar Hernandez, and Trent Thornton along with guys on the way like Vladdy, Jr., Bo Bichette, Anthony Alford, Cavan Biggio and Nate Pearson is undeniable. Some will make it and some won’t, but hopefully a few of them will be a part of the next great Blue Jays team.

Not even a little bit. I was 19, it was something fun to do, but I never imagined it as a career and certainly never thought I would ever get to do a single big-league game, let alone be in a major-league broadcast booth for 18 seasons and counting. After that 1989 season was over, I went back to school at U of T and was going to go to law school. I wrote the LSAT after second year and was looking into law schools (I did really well on the LSAT but my overall marks were pretty average, so I don’t really know what sorts of options I had as far as schools), but a couple of older cousins of mine who are lawyers – one of whom was the Attorney General of Ontario at the time – warned me about the long hours, the tons of grunt work, never seeing your family, and advised me to pursue what I was passionate about rather than become a lawyer because it seemed like a good idea. So all this is their fault.