Examining what the Blue Jays should do with the centre field position in 2027

Examining what the Blue Jays should do with the centre field position in 2027
Photo credit: © Cary Edmondson-Imagn Images
Cynthia Ryley Delaney
Nov 16, 2026, 16:00 ESTUpdated: Nov 16, 2026, 13:29 EST
Most of the Toronto Blue Jays’ needs are evident.
Without question, their biggest need is an impact bat, potentially even two. More specifically, they have a need for a corner outfielder and second baseman. Ideally, those players can hit left-handed pitching, as they were one of the worst teams against southpaw pitching in 2026.
On the mound, they also learned the hard way last season that a team can never have too much pitching, so adding a starter is a must. And who knows, maybe they even look to improve their already excellent bullpen.
But there’s another potential need for the Blue Jays, a centre fielder.
Throughout their window of contention, the Blue Jays had stability at the position. George Springer played the position for his first two seasons, then they acquired Daulton Varsho and Kevin Kiermaier during the 2022-23 off-season. Varsho eventually took the role as an everyday player, that was until he was traded before the 2026 trade deadline.
Just days before the Jays traded Varsho, they acquired Brett Bateman from the Chicago Cubs for Kevin Gausman. Essentially, it was a trade that featured a fan-favourite, but they also got a fan-favourite in return.
So a question that must be answered is Bateman ready to be their everyday centre fielder, and if not, what should the Blue Jays do about centre field?

Is Brett Bateman ready to be the Blue Jays’ everyday centre fielder?

Bateman was a big reason why the Blue Jays were even in the playoff race in September. Joining the team on August 7th, the 24-year-old slashed .329/.402/.424 with two home runs in 181 plate appearances, good for a 138 wRC+. All of this was done with an unsustainable BABIP of .410.
Bateman excelled defensively in centre field. In 288 innings at one of the most important positions in baseball, Bateman finished with 6 Defensive Runs Saved, 3 Outs Above Average, and 4 Fielding Run Value.
Defence alone is probably enough to get his bat in the lineup, but he is a prototypical lead-off hitter of a bygone era. He’s speedy, he slaps the balls and finds gaps, and he goes deep every once in a while.
He’s due for a regression, but even with that regression, he still has the tools to be the team’s everyday centre fielder.

If not Bateman, then who in the organization can play centre field?

There could be a few in-house options to eat some innings in centre field. General manager Ross Atkins spoke to the media during the GM meetings, and mentioned Nathan Lukes and Addison Barger as options to play centre field.
Although Lukes has mainly played in the corner outfield in his four big league seasons, he does have some experience in centre field. Overall, he has amassed 306 innings at the position in the big leagues, including 60 in 2026 and 214 in 2025 while Varsho was out with an injury. Coming up the minor league ladder as an outfielder, Lukes also played 2,609.1 innings in centre field in the minor leagues, including 504.2 innings there in 2022.
Barger has never played centre field in his professional career. He began his career as a shortstop, with experience at second base before settling on third thanks to a strong arm. In 2023, Barger began playing in right field, which is essentially the only outfield position he’s played in his career, aside from 55 innings in left during the 2024 season.
Those are just the two outfielders Atkins mentioned. Jonatan Clase came up the minor league ladder as a centre fielder and has the skill set to play the position. He has speed, good range, and a solid arm. The bat has been the big concern since the Blue Jays acquired him before the 2024 trade deadline.
There’s another option, RJ Schreck. On Tuesday, the Jays will need to decide whether or not to add him to the 40-man roster to protect him from the Rule 5 Draft. While they can probably get away with it due to Schreck missing a large chunk of the 2026 season due to injury, he has some experience playing centre field as well.

Defensive versatility could open opportunities for prospects in the corner outfield

If Barger and Lukes play some centre field, it opens up some opportunities for other players to play in the corner infield. Both Sean Keys and Charles McAdoo got some looks in left field in 2026, as their position in the infield is essentially blocked. 
With the Jays platooning Lukes, Barger, and Bateman in centre field, Keys and/or McAdoo could become mainstays on the team. That obviously depends on what happens with Anthony Santander, as well as if the Blue Jays add another outfield bat.
Another corner outfielder bat to keep an eye on is Aaron Parker. He made a name for himself by winning the Arizona Fall League Home Run Derby, but Parker also hit 19 home runs in Double-A this season. The strikeout rate was high and he has limited experience in left field, but there’s potential in that bat.
The Jays can also look elsewhere for a bench bat to play in the corner outfield, perhaps some that address a need. There are some defensively sound outfielders who can play centre field, as well as some right-handed outfielders who mash lefties. Let’s take a look at those players in the next section.

Free agent outfielders

We won’t cover players like Randy Arozarena, Teruaki Satō, and Seiya Suzuki here. Those three players address a different need that is out of the scope of this article. This section covers centre fielders, bench bats with a speciality, and a potential replacement for Straw.
Straw brought a few things to the Blue Jays. He rarely struck out, gave good at bats, was a right-handed batter, and played solid defence. There are a few bench bats who could provide the same value.
The best of the bunch is Mauricio Dubón. While his bat has always been below average, Dubón has played 1,344.2 career big league innings in centre field. That’s not the only position he’s played, as he’s also played right field, left field, shortstop, third base, second base, and even some first base in his career. He also excels defensively anywhere that you put him.
There is a downside though, as the right-handed batter has been a reverse splits hitter in two of the last three seasons, meaning Dubón hits right-handed pitchers better than left-handed pitchers.
Acquiring Dubón would give the Blue Jays a super-utility player, essentially taking the role that Josh Smith had in 2026. Edmundo Sosa is another option for this role, as he’s a solid defensive infielder who also played 182 innings in left field last season.
He hasn’t played much centre field in his career, but his bat is better than Dubón’s. In 2025, Sosa slashed .276/.307/.469 with 11 home runs in just 261 plate appearances for a 110 wRC+, the third time he’s finished his career with a wRC+ that is above-average.
Also a right-handed batter, Sosa has always posted good numbers against southpaw pitching. In his career, Sosa is slashing .273/.326/.479 with 24 home runs in 668 plate appearances for a 119 wRC+ against southpaws. Against righties, he’s slashing just .245/.292/.374 with 21 home runs in 946 plate appearances for an 81 wRC+.
Bringing up the name “Randal Grichuk” in 2026 may be controversial, but it’s insane how much of a fit he is. Against southpaws in 2026, the Jays slashed .229/.298/.361 with 41 home runs, for an 85 wRC+. All five of those statistics ranked in the bottom five when stacked up against the 29 other big league teams.
Since Grichuk was traded by the Blue Jays ahead of the 2022 season, he has found his niche as a lefty masher. Among players with 600 plate appearances against southpaws since the beginning of the 2022 season, Grichuk’s 144 wRC+ is eighth and his 43 home runs is tied for 11th.
Aaron Judge, Paul Goldschmidt, Yordan Álvarez, Jose Altuve, Yandy Díaz, Ketel Marte, and Willson Contreras are the only players with 600+ plate appearances that have a better wRC+ than Grichuk against LHP since the start of the 2022 season. He’s a totally different player than he was with the Blue Jays.
Grichuk’s defence in the outfield has ranged from fine to not great over his career. Last season, he split his time between serving as the designated hitter and playing left field, while also playing 12 games in right field. If the Jays go down the path of acquiring Grichuk for a second time (which I am totally on board for), he gives the Blue Jays a bench bat who excels at an area they struggled in last season.
Unlike Dubón and Sosa, Tyrone Taylor has strictly played in the outfield in his career. Defensively, he’s solid, posting 42 Defensive Runs Saved, 22 Outs Above Average, and 24 Fielding Run Value in 4,246 innings in the outfield. He’s played significant innings in centre field, as well, so he’s a good replacement for Straw in that regard, but also because there’s a bit more impact with the bat. 
Of course, Straw is still an option as well. From all accounts, he’s a glue guy in the club house and still provides valuable defence in all three outfield positions. He’ll make far less than he would’ve had the Jays exercised his option, but there’s no doubt interest between the two parties.
But what about if the Blue Jays believe Bateman is ready for full-time action? How does the centre field market in free agency look? Honestly, not great.
There are two real options, former Blue Jay Daulton Varsho and Trent Grisham. The Athletic’s Mitch Bannon reported on his show Blue Bird Territory that the “Blue Jays are poking around on Varsho”, while Sportsnet’s Shi Davidi reported that they had interest in Grisham.
Varsho is obviously familiar with the team, and on top of good defence, the centre fielder was terrific in 2025 (when healthy). Across 271 plate appearances, he slashed .238/.284/.548, but also hit 20 home runs, well on pace for 40 had he reached his average plate appearance total from the last four years (excluding 2025). The same can’t be said for his 2026 season.
Grisham also had a really strong 2025 season, slashing .235/.348/.464 with 34 home runs in 581 plate appearances for a 128 wRC+. He received a qualifying offer from the New York Yankees, accepted it, then slashed just .211/.308/.395 with 18 home runs in 484 plate appearances for a 98 wRC+. Varsho was dealing with cysts in his wrist, and his defence is far better than Grisham’s.
That said, signing either player is less than ideal, and the Blue Jays should look to either add a corner outfielder with a specialty (Grichuk), a super utility player (Dubón or Sosa), or a late-game defensive replacement (Taylor or Straw).
We’ll see what happens!

Cynthia Ryley Delaney is a Nation Network writer for Blue Jays Nation, DFOEdmonton, and DFOCalgary. She can be followed on Twitter @CynthiaRDelaney.