Sports were once a safe haven from the tire fire of everyday life, but one of the most debated topics has now encroached upon the sports realm: artificial intelligence.
Earlier this week, many posts on social media circulated about a new sports podcast network called Beatline Sports. To the untrained eye, it looked just like any other harmless startup, but there was one issue: the hosts and the content were completely AI-generated.
The internet, as expected, revolted. Clip after clip from some of these Beatline podcasts emerged with inaccurate information, the “hosts” mispronouncing player names, all while providing no real substance. They were supposed to mimic a two-person podcast and sounded anything but.
Meanwhile, there are countless podcasts out there, produced, written, and researched by real people who are either doing this as a passion project or are the industrious ones who have turned their passion into a full-time podcasting career.
While it was disappointing to hear Blue Jays players like Louis Varland being mispronounced “Lew-iss Vaar-land” by Beatline’s hosts, Blue Jays podcasters like Peddle and Paleolog weren’t all that surprised to see the firestorm of disapproval for artificial intelligence’s ill attempt at generating sports content.
“I knew one day, someone or some organization was going to try to do an AI podcast,” Peddle said during an interview with Blue Jays Nation. “In the back of my mind, I was always thinking: ‘Why would I, as a consumer, listen to a podcast?’ The main reason people listen to or watch a podcast is the people they want to listen to. It’s the personality they have.
“When I heard this podcast, it’s exactly what I thought; there wasn’t a lot of personality, it was very bland, it felt like ChatGPT scripts. It’s something to note and it raises an eyebrow. Maybe one day they get better, but right now, I’m not threatened by this.”
Since starting the podcast in 2020, Blue Jays Today has released around 1,500 episodes during its six-year run, in addition to 4,000 to 5,000 pieces of short-form video content that serve as an “elevator pitch” or “advertisement” for the podcast, as Peddle puts it.
Beatline boasts a tsunami of content, allegedly releasing 300-plus daily podcast episodes across its network. Most of it is unlistenable, littered with random sound effects and as much personality as a doorstop. The overwhelming consensus from sports fans was: “Why would anybody listen to this?”
Founder Ibnul Jaif Farabi claims to produce this content for mere pennies, and the results are slop personified.
Podnews.net also reported that this is the same person who was cloning upward of 75 history podcasts earlier this year and repurposing them as original content.
On the other end of the spectrum, there are genuine fans who have parlayed their passion for their favourite team into a successful empire, as another popular Blue Jays podcast,
Gate 14, also proves.
With 20,000 subscribers on YouTube, its own giveaway day at Rogers Centre this year, and episodes featuring in-depth tours of the Rogers Centre, Gate 14 has become one of the top podcasts in the space since the show’s inception in 2022. Just like the minds behind Blue Jays Today, Gate 14 doesn’t feel that AI will intrude on its unique space.
“I thought it was kind of strange,” Gate 14 said in an X direct message. “I more so walked away with it kind of grateful; it’s hard to replicate, to a certain extent, what we have created here with Gate 14, as with all other podcasts in general. Every [Beatline] clip I see, they screw up players’ names and simple things like contracts. It’s a very bad product.”
Sports fandom was one of the last bastions of freedom from artificial intelligence, but with AI’s surge in popularity over the last few years, it was only a matter of time before someone saw an opportunity to flood the market with sports content. By employing the spray-and-pray method, Beatline Sports seems to present itself as a legitimate entity to unsuspecting listeners who may not know any better.
If this content is cheap to produce and post, it doesn’t take much for this company to turn a profit. Most of the team podcast pages have links to Buy Me a Coffee, where listeners can “keep every episode free — a coffee keeps the mics on.”
There is no mic to be seen, and no hosts exist, even though the hosts of Blue Jays Beatline are named “Melissa Foster” and “Ryan Doyle.” To date, Beatline has two supporters on Buy Me a Coffee.
Perhaps releasing subpar content to farm clicks and media coverage was Beatline Sports’ plan all along. By giving air to this cause, it’s likely generated thousands of pageviews and podcast listens. Aside from the initial hate-listen to hear how outrageous the content is, that isn’t a recipe for long-term success.
“Whoever started Beatline, I understand why they did it and I don’t want to attack them at all,” Peddle said. “They’re trying a thing with technology that’s out there. But I appreciate the support of the general public that understands that this is the type of content we’re not looking for, and we want to support real people putting in the time and the effort every single day, making it their careers, and engaging with the public.”
If anything, the emergence of Beatline Sports has created a groundswell of support for the people producing actual podcasts in the space. Listeners will continue to show their love for podcasts covering the Blue Jays, such as Blue Jays Today and Gate 14.
Artificial intelligence has already replaced some jobs, but judging by the content Beatline is spewing, folks in the sports podcasting space are safe for now. So long as there’s an appetite for takes from people who actually watch and support these teams, Blue Jays podcasts have nothing to worry about.
That’s not to say this AI content won’t continue to improve as the models become smarter, but there’s no replacement for the pain and suffering a true baseball fan endures after a walk-off loss. That’s the kind of misery only a human can experience; the type of commiseration group therapy that fans still yearn for.
PRESENTED BY THE PERFECT 9 COLLECTION
Some baseball traditions never get old.
The Perfect 9 Collection is our newest limited-edition collaboration with Blue Jays Today, inspired by the viral 9/9/9 challenge that has become a staple of baseball culture. Whether you’re taking on the challenge or just enjoying a day at the ballpark, this collection celebrates the moments that make baseball unforgettable. Featuring premium Levelwear apparel with elevated fabrics and modern fits, it’s designed for fans who live and breathe the game—on game day and beyond. Limited edition. Premium quality. Built for baseball fans. Shop the Perfect 9 Collection while it lasts. Exclusively at
nationgear.ca