Aaron Sanchez left the game after three innings (and 64 pitches) with what the #BlueJays are calling a right middle finger nail avulsion. The Internet tells me nail avulsion is when part, or all, of the nail is torn away or removed from the nail bed.
Sanchez leaves game against Rays with finger nail avulsion

Photo credit: Nick Turchiaro-USA TODAY Sports
May 27, 2019, 15:41 EDTUpdated: May 27, 2019, 17:02 EDT
After 64 pitches through three innings against the Tampa Bay Rays on Monday afternoon, starter Aaron Sanchez left the game due to a right middle finger nail avulsion.
Just more tough news for the 26-year-old after battling through various injuries his whole career. In 2018, he pitched a total of 105 innings — the second-most in his career — so far in 2019, with 60 innings pitched he would have been on-track to surpass that total.
Before Monday’s game, Sanchez had a 3.79 ERA and a 1.456 WHIP this season.
Already lacking starting pitching, the Blue Jays will most likely rely on more “bullpen days” as manager Charlie Montoyo puts it. Even if Sanchez isn’t out for a very long time, the Jays risking him with every start and running out of their slowly-decaying bullpen, is unfortunate to say the least.
If Sanchez heads to the IL, a resulting transaction bringing up a possible starter will happen.
UPDATE:
Okay, so it looks like it isn’t serious.
Aaron Sanchez says nail lifted from skin but didn’t tear off. Says least severe of three incidents this season.
Breaking News
- John Schneider returns for 2026 season as Blue Jays exercise contract option
- Don Mattingly steps down from Blue Jays bench coach role
- Blue Jays: Bo Bichette receives qualifying offer
- The Blue Jays have a challenging and delicate task this offseason
- It’s not urgent, but the Blue Jays should consider signing Trey Yesavage to a contract extension this offseason
