Blue Jays could “aggressively” shop Stroman and Sanchez

I wrote yesterday on the importance of the next few months for the Shapiro era rebuild because of how badly the front office needs to get a quality return on their three big arms.

Whether we believe the Blue Jays should hang on to one of, or all of Marcus Stroman, Aaron Sanchez, or Ken Giles for the long-term is moot at this point because it’s fairly inevitable all of them are going to get moved. To wit, Jayson Stark wrote today in The Athletic that the Jays could “aggressively” shop their two veteran starters well before the July 31 trade deadline.

Almost everyone is gone now from the 2015-2016 playoff teams. But the Blue Jays have already signaled they could be aggressive in trying to trade Marcus Stroman and Aaron Sanchez, who will both be a year and a half from free agency. And “they’re in the perfect place to move guys like that,” one of the execs quoted earlier said. “Their entire fan base is sold on the concept that guys like Vlad [Guerrero] and [Cavan] Biggio are their future. So they won’t even be paying attention [to those trades] because they understand they’re building around the young guys.”

At this point, this report is hardly news. While we may believe that it’s prudent for the Jays’ rebuild-to-contention arc to hang on to a good, youngish starter like Stroman, it’s no mystery that the front office is going to lean towards rebuilding with their own guys. Besides, as we saw last year, the Tampa Bay Rays made the tough decision to deal ace Chris Archer, and the return of Tyler Glasnow and Austin Meadows has done wonders for the team this season.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

One unfortunate thing for the Blue Jays is the reality that Dallas Keuchel still floating around on the free agent market dilutes the value of Stroman and Sanchez in a trade. If a team is uncomfortable with the price tag the Jays set on their starters, they could wait until after the draft and throw a bunch of money at Keuchel without having to give up any prospect capital.

Of course, only one team can sign Keuchel. A team like Oakland or Minnesota with a smaller budget might not be in the mix for such a thing, so the Jays are likely to wait things out and start a bidding war among the teams that don’t end up signing Keuchel. Given the fact the Jays are dealing a-year-and-a-half of Stroman and Sanchez, they can be a little more patient because pulling the trigger in July rather than June doesn’t have the ramifications of the other team acquiring 10 starts rather than 15 in the sense of a rental.

So, yeah! Enjoy your Stroman and Sanchez starts for the next few weeks, because, whether we like it or not, this is happening.

  • OopsConfirmed

    I don’t get the logic here, but, then again, I’m not privy to what’s being offered for these two.

    Wouldn’t signing Stro and Sanchez to extensions work better for the early part of the window for contending? Granted, they won’t be aces, but they will be solid mid to back of the rotations starters. Sanchez might be in the bullpen. Regardless, you can’t contend without pitching and I see no avenue for the Jays to get pitching for the early part of the contention window. Their pitching prospects are pretty far away.

    But what about the trade value of these two? To hold out hope that Stroman or Sanchez will get a return like the Rays got for Archer seems to overvalue the Jays pitchers. Before this season, Archer was measurably better than either of these two. In the two seasons before the trade, Archer’s total fWar was 7.5 (12.6! if you go back three seasons, but this makes comparing to Stroman difficult because of Stro’s injury in 2015). Both Stro and Sanchez are 4.6 over their previous two seasons. Further, Sanchez’s infamous fingernail is going to reduce his value immensely.

    What are people projecting the return for these two will be? How will the Jays fill their rotation without them when they are expecting to contend? The Jays are already in dire need of pitching that will be ready when Vlad, Cavan and Bo have matured. How does trading these two help that situation? Does anyone think they’re going to get good pitching prospects that are about 2 years away from the bigs in return? I don’t see it.

    • Cam Lewis

      I think the plan would be to deal the three (Stroman, Sanchez, and Giles) for prospects in positions of need, and then dip into the free agent market and use the money you would have used on those three on different players.

  • Starvenger

    It’s happening! Unless it isn’t.

    I’ve half accepted that these guys are likely gone. The other half hopes that the ghost of Cafardo is possessing writers and getting them to say that various Jays are getting traded.