September 12 Gameday: Blue Jays turn to bullpen day looking to bounce back Vs. Orioles

Photo credit: Dennis Lee-Imagn Images
Sep 12, 2026, 14:12 EDT
With just over two weeks left in the regular season, the Toronto Blue Jays are running out of time to continue spiralling against teams below them in the Wild Card hunt.
After a series loss to the Athletics, Toronto dropped the first of a three-game set last night to Baltimore; something they cannot afford to repeat going forward if they want any chance of October baseball.
Friday got off to a tough start with Dylan Beavers hitting a leadoff home run against Max Scherzer, before the Orioles added five more runs in the second inning; a lead they never relinquished. Overall, Scherzer finished with five innings pitched, six earned runs, one walk and three strikeouts. Braydon Fisher was the only other Blue Jay to allow a run when Coby Mayo took him deep for a solo shot in the seventh inning to give Baltimore their seventh and final run.
Toronto’s offence was weak against former Jay Chris Bassitt, besides a Kazuma Okamoto solo home run in the fourth inning. It wasn’t until the ninth inning that the Blue Jays started showing signs of fight, when Brett Bateman connected for his first career Major League home run, bringing the score to 7-4. The team couldn’t rally any further and eventually picked up their second straight loss. 1-10 with RISP just won’t cut it in a postseason race.
The Guardians were able to come back against the Twins Friday night, meaning the Jays are now two games out of the final Wild Card spot in the American League, though they hold the tie-breaker with Cleveland. With a 73-75 record and a limping offence, Toronto can’t rely on Cleveland losing to squeak into the playoffs. They will need to prove an ability to rack up wins and do so quickly.
Spencer Miles gets the ball for the Blue Jays in game two of this series, with a goal in mind to throw between 40-45 pitches. Given his stellar rookie season and vast arsenal of pitches, the prospect of Miles as a starting pitcher is certainly intriguing; something the Blue Jays may look to exploit down the stretch. Thus far, the Rule 5 draft pick has a 2.77 ERA across 87.2 innings pitched.
Miles has performed better in the bullpen, but with Shane Bieber’s status unknown and Trey Yesavage likely not having enough time to build up to a starter’s workload, the team may turn to Miles and his dynamic sinker/curveball combination to function as a fourth starter for the final few weeks of the season. Spencer Arrighetti is expected to throw the bulk of the innings today and is seeking his first win as a Blue Jay.
On the other hand, Kyle Bradish gets the ball for the Orioles, coming off an adequate outing against Boston in which he tossed four scoreless innings while walking four batters. It has been an up-and-down year for Bradish, who once finished top five in Cy Young voting back in 2023. The last time he faced the Blue Jays was at the Rogers Centre in early June, a game in which he allowed five runs on nine hits and made it through just four innings.
The Blue Jays‘ lineup features four right-handed hitters: George Springer, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Alejandro Kirk, and Kazuma Okamoto.
Lefties include: Brett Bateman, Nathan Lukes, Josh Smith, Andres Gimenez and Rudy Martin Jr.
Location: Rogers Centre – Toronto, Ontario
First Pitch: 7:07 p.m. ET
Watch/Listen: Sportsnet One, SN590
Starting Pitchers
Toronto Blue Jays – Spencer Miles: 6-2 record, 2.77 ERA, 87.2 IP, 81 SO, 21 BB
Baltimore Orioles – Kyle Bradish: 7-13 record, 3.91 ERA, 152 IP, 140 SO, 68 BB
Lineups:
Blue Jays:
- Brett Bateman – CF
- George Springer – DH
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr. – 1B
- Alejandro Kirk – C
- Nathan Lukes – RF
- Kazuma Okamoto – 3B
- Josh Smith – 2B
- Andrés Giménez – SS
- Rudy Martin Jr. – LF
Orioles:
- Dylan Beavers – LF
- Pete Alonso – 1B
- Jackson Holliday – 2B
- Coby Mayo – DH
- Gunnar Henderson – SS
- Christian Encarnacion-Strand – 3B
- Heston Kjerstad – RF
- Colton Cowser – CF
- Carlos Narvaez – C
Sponsored by bet365
Breaking News
- September 12 Gameday: Blue Jays turn to bullpen day looking to bounce back Vs. Orioles
- Former Blue Jay Eric Lauer shifted to 60-day IL, ending 2026 season
- Examining the other Wild Card contenders’ schedules
- How Alejandro Kirk’s return to form has helped the Blue Jays’ playoff push
- Anthony Santander singles in second rehab game with Triple-A Buffalo
