What Should The Blue Jays Do With Kendrys Morales?

Kendrys Morales has been on a tear as of late. He was named American League player of the week after hitting a homering in seven straight games, slashing a ridiculous .478/.500/.1391 for the week of August 20th. That stretch of seven games brought him up to .264/.343/.484 on the year, which seems like a miracle given what happened the first six weeks of the season.

I wrote about it in May, but here’s pretty much what went down: through Morales’ first few weeks, he hit a ton of balls on the ground, and because he’s a designated hitter in his mid-30s and not a speedy middle of the diamond player, was pretty much a sure out almost every time he came to the plate. He hit only .146/.239/.260 to start the year, which may just seem like a small bump in the road now, but that was over an excruciating 30 game stretch.

It was easy to look at his .158 BABIP and 93.4MPH average exit velocity – which ranked 15th out of 387 with at least 25 batted ball events through the first nine weeks of the season – as reasons for optimism, but unless his 54.2% ground ball rate came down, no significant positive regression was going to occur.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

And both happened.

Morales didn’t need to just hit line drives and fly balls to return to the player the Blue Jays thought they signed, he just needed to put less bad balls into play. His ground ball rate, even with that poor start, sat at 44.7% going into Monday’s series against the Orioles. To pretty much everybody’s surprise, he has gone from a player that fans were begging to be DFA’ed into the best hitter on the Blue Jays through the summer. From May 19th to Monday, Morales has hit .308/.382/.569 with a 155 wRC+ in 78 games.

You can measure how good a slugger is not by batting average or on base percentage, but isolated slugging (ISO), a measure of the ability to hit for extra bases. Over those 78 games, Morales’ .260 ISO ranked him 20th out of 332 hitters with at least 100 at bats in that span. This is more than a single hot streak, the guy that everybody hated back in April and May has been legitimately good.

So now it’s time to ask: what do the Blue Jays do with him?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The team obviously isn’t currently in a position to contend next year, and Morales will be entering the final year of his contract and his age 36 season. One of the arguments against being patient with his cold spell to start 2018 was that having him in everyday limits your ability to be creative with your day-to-day lineups with him pretty much being glued to the DH spot. With all the young MLB ready talent the Blue Jays on the cusp of the Major Leagues, I’m not sure you should have somebody like that on the 25-man roster. They already have too many infielders as it is. Hell, even the crowded outfield should be a reason to not carry a DH. There are a lot of guys fighting for three spots and the most intriguing one of them, Teoscar Hernandez, can hit the hell out of a baseball, but for some reason, I only hear one thing when he’s patrolling the outfield. A freed up DH spot every so often can help give him a break from playing out there, and us a break from having to watch him play out there.

Another thing to consider is the Josh Donaldson situation. We know that Vladimir Guerrero Jr’s light rapping on the door in March has turned into full blown kicks to the point where there might not even be a door by the time he’s called up sometime in April 2019. He’ll be on the team. If the Blue Jays decide to bring Donaldson back for less money on a qualifying offer, he will be too. This is where the value of that DH spot comes in. You’re not going to have the number one prospect in baseball sit on the bench after you made him wait this long for a call up, and you sure as hell aren’t going to pay your former franchise third baseman somewhere in the $18 million dollar range to do it either, especially when both sides are banking on him regaining value.

I’m not sure what an aging designated hitter would command in a trade, but the Blue Jays could build on a shrewd July 30th deadline by eating some, or hopefully all, of the $12 million owed to him in 2019, and flipping him to a contending team.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

That would be a hefty $30 million dollars spent towards a few mid-level prospects and an open DH spot. Would it be worth it?

They certainly won’t get a big name back, but after his past few months, Morales might have built up enough value to actually get a non-org guy in a trade for him, instead of paying him to go away like many in Toronto thought was his fate in April. The real value as 2019 goes on would be the player development and making sure that nobody is losing too many at-bats that need them.

Or, you know, they can just keep him around the final year, because it kind of seems like he’s had an impact on some of the kids…

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

  • Jeff2sayshi

    Thank you for the Morales article. It’s been long overdue. And also thank you for pointing out that he’s basically been at it for 3 months now.

    As for what to do… Play the hell out of him at first for the next month, and see if you can trade him in the offseason.

  • Kristen Sprague

    There’s no room for him next year as he blocks younger, cheaper players and he won’t be a part of the next great Blue Jay team. Get what you can for him

  • Peter Gowdy

    I don’t think the Jays need to be in a hurry to think about dealing Morales. They could do it over the winter instead of trying to see what they’d get before the August 31 deadline. But all of these thoughts are rather complicated. The Josh Donaldson situation complicates it all too. I’d rather see trying to move Russell Martin than Kendrys, even at a substantial dollar loss. With Russ taking up 3rd base while Jansen grows into his full-time job behind the plate, Russ gets in the way of the large list of infielders too. And there’s Tulo. Griffin makes a good case for Tulo competing for the shortstop job next spring, and I think it is unlikely we are able to move him without paying his entire salary. With Gurriel looking like the SS of the future (let alone Bo Bichette) and Vladdy at 3rd, and who among Travis, Solarte, and Diaz at 2nd, plus the legit 4 outfielders vying for 3 spots, I’d say keeping Kendrys Morales would be a good idea at least until the offseason. They have until almost December to figure out the Donaldson Qualifying Offer. Perhaps they can package up a bunch of decent parts for a decent starter, and just maybe 2019 is not a write-off just yet.

  • dolsh

    “The team obviously isn’t currently in a position to contend next year”

    People keep saying this. It’s not true. The team is very obviously in a position where is could contend for a WC. The “if’s” can go both ways.

    • Richard Lee-Sam

      I agree with that, but contending for a wildcard isn’t being in a spot to contend.

      At the beginning of this year, I personally believed that they would be in the WC discussion, but I wouldn’t label them as contenders. Contenders ship out futures to open their window. As of right now, they’re not necessarily selling, but they’re cutting out a lot of weight (Pearce, Happ, etc.). They’re more focused on their long term future than winning right now. That’s what I think a contender is.

      • Paul Beestons Grass Surface

        So if it was boxing, the only contender would be the guy ranked #1. Otherwise, everyone else, until they climb to that #1 position are only contending to be the #1 contender, but aren’t neccessarily contenders.

        I have to disagree with you. If you make the playoffs, anything can happen in a 7 game series. Does contending only for a WC spot make you the favorite? Nah, but you are on the dance floor and it’s a new season.