With the All-Star break just under a week away, it seems like the Toronto Blue Jays are trying to limp to the finish line.

Their most recent homestand was disappointing, dropping both the Texas Rangers and the Houston Astros series before eeking out a win over the New York Mets, and now the club is slogging along on a West Coast road trip that has produced one win in just four games. While clubs go through ups and downs throughout the regular season, the Jays giving up 10+ runs on two different occasions since jetting over to Seattle and San Francisco is a tough pill to swallow for a club that was expecting much more.

Truth be told, the Jays just look lost in multiple facets.

Their bread and butter was their defensive prowess, and we’ve seen this team make fundamental errors regularly. A team that was built on ‘do damage’ and ‘pass the baton’ at the plate can’t find a rhythm, and not a single player on the team boasts an OPS over .800. Their pitching is sitting in the middle of the pack, one of the club’s saving graces this season, but cracks in the armour are starting to show. If some of the stalwarts in Dylan Cease, Trey Yesavage, Tyler Rogers, and Louis Varland start to trend in the wrong direction, it will be an extremely tough hill to overcome.

If it wasn’t for the AL East being an absolute dumpster fire this season, the Jays would 100% be in sell mode this trade deadline. The club has quite a few expiring contracts – Gausman, George Springer, Shane Bieber, Daulton Varsho, and Max Scherzer – but no player is really providing the ‘wow’ factor this season when it comes to trade value. Gausman has struggled to find that ‘ace’ mentality over his past three starts, and Springer is a shade of his former 2025 self. Bieber and Scherzer have struggled to stay healthy this season and aren’t providing much value on the diamond when they are healthy anyway.

As it currently stands, the Jays are just 3.5 games out of a Wild Card spot in the American League, which is just a further testament to how unhinged the AL is this season that a team seven games below .500 is even sniffing a postseason spot. This is why the Jays are likely still at a crossroads on what the future holds this season in terms of being buyers and sellers.

We’ve seen what this team can do when things are firing on all cylinders, and while the injury bug has definitely played a part in their shaky start to the 2026 season, it’s not a valid excuse at this point in the year when a good chunk of the roster is slotted with regulars. That being said, if the club were to add a bat or two and a starter who can avoid the injured list, there is a fair argument to be made that the Jays can sneak into the postseason as a Wild Card entry and then figure it out from there. Toronto just needs an invite to the dance, and then anything can happen, so to speak.

However, the devil’s advocate also points towards the front office being sellers and ridding themselves of some of these contracts as they prepare for an offseason that will likely hit the back burner given the current CBA talks. Gausman and Varsho hold the most trade value, and the rest of the group is just salary-shedding fodder at this point, except for Scherzer, who would be the ‘one last kick at the can’ candidate.

These next two weeks will be huge for the Blue Jays. A continued fall from grace will fuel the fire for being sellers, and with good reason. Get something from the expiring deals while mirroring the 2024 season of ‘let the kids play’ and see what you have for 2027 (if there even is a season). On the other hand, if the Jays can magically find a winning mentality over the coming weeks and enter the Wild Card again, the ‘buyer’ part of the conversation will certainly be at the forefront.

Overall, there is no concrete answer at this point. The Blue Jays are entering a tough stretch that will really show the direction this club will take for the rest of the season. Some of the bigger bats and veteran arms on this team will need to step up if they want to be playoff contenders, and if the club can’t figure it out, it’s the responsibility of the front office to pivot accordingly to salvage what they can for future seasons.

It’s a trying time for Jays fans. And it’s really not going to get any easier through July as this club continues to figure out the outlook for 2027.

Stay ahead of the first pitch! From breaking news, unexpected trades and must-read analysis, BlueJaysNation delivers the insight serious Jays fans rely on—straight to your inbox. Sign up for the Bluejaysnation newsletter here!