Blue Jays: Examining which teams could be a suitor for Brandon Valenzuela

Blue Jays: Examining which teams could be a suitor for Brandon Valenzuela
Photo credit: © Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images
Cynthia Ryley Delaney
Nov 20, 2026, 13:30 ESTUpdated: Nov 20, 2026, 11:29 EST
The Toronto Blue Jays have their fair share of needs this off-season.
Those needs, namely adding a power bat or two, a starting pitcher, and potentially a reliever, are well known. But the Blue Jays also have one surplus that could help them in a pursuit of a trade.
Brandon Valenzuela, acquired by the Blue Jays for Will Wagner ahead of the 2025 trade deadline, became a Major League Baseball mainstay in 2026. Called up early into the season after Alejandro Kirk went down with an injury, Valenzuela quickly usurped Tyler Heineman as the team’s back up catcher.
As a whole, it was a successful rookie season for the catcher, as he slashed .222/.307/.372 with nine home runs in 271 plate appearances, good for a 93 wRC+ and 2.1 fWAR. However, Valenzuela’s defensive acumen was in full display this past season, finishing as a Gold Glove finalist and posting 9 Defensive Runs Saved and 13 Fielding Run Value behind the plate.
When Kirk returned, Valenzuela’s playing time was diminished, but before that, he also showed some promise with the bat. From the start of the season until June 13th, Valenzuela slashed .254/.338/.454 with seven of his nine home runs, good for a 123 wRC+.
With regular playing time, Valenzuela showed he is capable of being an everyday catcher, an opportunity he won’t get with the Blue Jays. It makes sense that teams across the league have interest in the switch-hitter 26-year-old, as reported by The Athletic’s Mitch Bannon last week.
Bannon listed the Reds as one of the teams that has interest in Valenzuela, but who are some other teams that could use a catcher this off-season? Let’s find out!

Cincinnati Reds

Tyler Stephenson played the majority of the games behind the plate for the Reds last season, slashing .241/.323/.404 with 15 home runs for a 99 wRC+ and 1.3 fWAR. He’s never been great defensively, but more of a concern for the Reds is that he’s a free agent.
Fangraphs projects that Jose Trevino will be their everyday starter in 2027, which is less than ideal. The former New York Yankee has yet to have a season with a wRC+ above average (100), slashing .217/.221/.336 with five home runs in 156 plate appearances in 2026. He’s a great defensive catcher, or at least was back in the day, but he’s also not a catcher a team wants to run every day.
The Reds’ top prospect according to MLB Pipeline, Alfredo Duno, is a catcher, but he only has experience in Double-A and has an ETA of 2028. Valenzuela is a cheap option as an everyday starter for the next two seasons at least, as he isn’t arbitration eligible until the 2028-29 off-season.

Chicago Cubs

Sticking in the National League Central, the Chicago Cubs could also be in need of a catcher. Carson Kelly spent the majority of the games as the Cubs’ backstop in 2026, slashing .258/.336/.376 with 10 home runs for a 103 wRC+, down from his 17 home runs in 2025. Kelly was around average defensively, but like Stephenson, he’s a free agent.
That leaves Miguel Amaya as their projected catcher according to Fangraphs. The 27-year-old had a solid 2026 season, slashing .237/.340/.377 with six home runs in 254 plate appearances, good for a 106 wRC+ and 1.4 fWAR. Defensively, he finished with 4 DRS and 1 FRV in 557.2 innings behind the plate.
Valenzuela, especially when he gets regular playing time, is an upgrade over Amaya. In the pipeline, Owen Ayers ranks as the Cubs’ second-best prospect according to MLB Pipeline.

Colorado Rockies

Of the teams listed here, the Colorado Rockies have the best catcher currently on their roster. Last season, Goodman slashed .245/.310/.529 with 41 home runs for a 112 wRC+. His home run totals were tied for sixth-best in Major League baseball in 2026. Add in slightly below-average defence behind the plate, and you may be questioning why the Rockies are a team that may have interest in Valenzuela.
Well, the small market club is in the midst of a rebuild, and as you can see from this article, at least a third of MLB can use an upgrade at the catching position. Goodman doesn’t become a free agent until after the 2029 season, meaning the Rockies can net a serious haul for the 27-year-old.
If they do deal him, and it seems within reason given the interest of contenders around the trade deadline, perhaps they look to Valenzuela to replace him?

Philadelphia Phillies

In his prime, J.T Realmuto was one of the best all around catchers in baseball, regularly posting seasons with a fWAR above 4.5, including a 6.7 fWAR season in 2022. But father time is undefeated, and Realmuto will turn 36 years old before the start of the 2027 season.
His game has seen a decline all across the board. With the bat in 2026, Realmuto slashed just .205/.283/.331 with 11 home runs in 467 plate appearances for a 68 wRC+. Behind the plate, Realmuto finished with -5 DRS and 0 FRV in 1,058.2 innings.
Realmuto has been a big part of the team for the 2020s, but they have to start thinking about the future at some point soon. Rafael Marchán is slated to be their backup catcher, according to Fangraphs, and he struggled mightily with the bat in 2026. They also don’t have much in the way for prospect catchers either.
While Valenzuela may never be able to produce what Realmuto did in his prime, Valenzuela has the potential to be a strong all-around catcher and an adequate replacement.

Cleveland Guardians

Similar to the Reds and Cubs, the Cleveland Guardians are in need of an everyday catcher. Last season, they went with a tandem of Patrick Bailey and Austin Hedges. The latter is a free agent after playing 77 games behind the plate and slashing .247/.325/.377 with six home runs in 247 plate appearances for a 100 wRC+. That’s the first time in his career he’s finished with a wRC+ that high, as Hedges has always been regarded as a strong defensive catcher.
Bailey is a similar type of catcher to Hedges. Now don’t get me wrong, I’m a big fan of Bailey as he’s probably the only catcher who has been better defensively than Kirk since 2022. But he offers very little with the bat, and that’s being generous.
If the Guardians wish to share time being the plate like they did in 2026, Valenzuela is a good replacement for Hedges. Not only is the Blue Jay a good defensive catcher, but he offers more with the bat.
It’s also worth noting that the Blue Jays and Guardians are common trading partners, making three major trades between the 2024-25 off-season and the 2025 trade deadline.

Los Angeles Angels

Valenzuela won the backup job from Heineman, who was DFA’d and later joined the Los Angeles Angels, avoiding arbitration this off-season. Well, reuniting the duo may make sense for the American League West team.
It really comes down to whether Moisés Ballesteros can stick at catcher. Projected to be their everyday catcher according to Fangraphs, the 23-year-old split played 65 of his 104 games as the designated hitter, and another 29 games behind the plate.
If the Angels don’t view him as a catcher moving forward, they’ll be in need of one for next season. When the Jays rocked a tandem of Valenzuela and Heineman while Kirk was injured, Valenzuela slashed .254/.338/.454 with seven home runs, so there’s a track record here.

Texas Rangers

Another American League West team with a former Blue Jay catcher are the Texas Rangers. Danny Jansen got the bulk of playing time behind the plate last season, slashing .203/.296/.381 with eight home runs in 227 plate appearances.
He and former Angel Logan O’Hoppe are projected to be the Rangers’ catching tandem next season, according to Fangraphs. O’Hoppe has struggled since he hit 20 home runs in 522 plate appearances back in 2024, and he finished with -17 DRS and -14 FRV last season. Jansen, who also finished below-average offensively, has seen his defensive abilities decline since he was nominated for a Gold Glove in 2019.
At the very least, acquiring Valenzuela would give the Rangers a strong defensive catcher who has a higher offensive ceiling than both O’Hoppe and Jansen.

New York Yankees

The Blue Jays and Yankees rarely make trades, with the most recent notable trade coming in 2018 when the Blue Jays traded J.A. Happ to the Bronx Bombers for Brandon Drury and Billy McKinney. Before that, you have to go back to just before the 1999 season for the last time a major trade was made.
With the Blue Jays and Yankees both looking to contend in 2027, it seems unlikely they’d be willing to swing a deal, but the Blue Jays do have a surplus of the position that the Yankees need.
The Yankees were one team interested in Goodman around the trade deadline, according to New York Post’s Jon Heyman. They didn’t get a deal done, but addressing their catching situation is an area of need for the American League East team this off-season.
Austin Wells played the bulk of the season there in 2026, slashing .186/.292/.332 with 14 home runs in 388 plate appearances, down from the 21 home runs he hit in 2025. Wells at least offers strong defence behind the plate, posting 8 DRS and 7 FRV in 959.1 innings there last season, but it’s clear that they want some more offence from the position.
If they were to acquire Valenzuela, he’d offer similar defensive acumen with a bit more potential with the bat (albeit with less power).
Time will tell if Valenzuela is dealt by the Blue Jays. They aren’t in a position where they need to move him, and trading the switch-hitting catcher would force them to find a backup catcher this off-season.

Cynthia Ryley Delaney is a Nation Network writer for Blue Jays Nation, DFOEdmonton, and DFOCalgary. She can be followed on Twitter @CynthiaRDelaney.