Trade Tree: Looking at both times the Blue Jays traded Jeff Hoffman

Photo credit: © Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images
Nov 20, 2026, 12:30 ESTUpdated: Nov 20, 2026, 07:57 EST
Jeff Hoffman’s two tenures with the Toronto Blue Jays are rather interesting.
Drafted by the Jays back in 2014, Hoffman has been dealt in two notable trade deadline moves a decade apart. Add in his season and a half of pitching for the team, and you have a pretty darn interesting career with the team.
In this edition of Trade Tree, we’ll look at the two Hoffman trades.
The 2015 trade
Drafted ninth overall in 2014 by the Blue Jays, the East Carolina alumni signed for a bonus of $3.1 million.
Hoffman never pitched for the Blue Jays in his first tenure, only making his professional debut with the team in 2015. He made 11 starts with the Dunedin Blue Jays, at the time the organization’s Advanced-A team, before making two starts with the New Hampshire Fisher Cats, also the Blue Jays’ Double-A team at the time.
The year prior, the Blue Jays were around a postseason spot before the trade deadline, but elected to not make a major move, something that franchise icon José Bautista criticized. Alex Anthopoulos, didn’t make the same mistake ahead of the 2015 trade deadline.
Entering July 28th’s slate of games, the Blue Jays had a 50-50 record and sat three games behind the final wild card spot. They swung a big trade that day, trading Hoffman, Miguel Castro, José Reyes, and Jesús Tinoco for LaTroy Hawkins and Troy Tulowitzki.
Hawkins, who was in his early 40s, was solid for the Jays. Over 18 games, he had a 2.76 ERA and 2.77 FIP across 16.1 innings of work. His postseason outings didn’t go nearly as well. But the main piece coming back was undoubtedly Tulowitzki.
The addition of Tulowitzki, and later David Price, helped the Blue Jays go 43-19 down the stretch, winning the American League East and hosting the Texas Rangers in the American League Divisional Series. Bautista’s home run is the most memorable moment from the series, and one of the most memorable home runs in team history, but Tulowitzki had some moments of his own.
Joining the team on the day after the trade, Tulowitzki went deep in just his second plate appearance with the team, going 3-5 with two doubles as well. He was far from the player he once was, but he gave the Blue Jays solid defence and slashed .239/.317/.380 with five home runs following the trade.
Down 2-0 in the series to the Rangers, Tulowitzki hit a three-run blast in the top of the sixth, turning a 2-0 lead into a 5-0 lead, as the Jays went on to eventually win that game and the series. In Game 3 of the American League Championship Series, he yet again hit another three-run home with the Blue Jays down 2-0 in the series, turning a 3-2 lead into a 6-2 lead.
His only season where he played more than 75 games with the Blue Jays was in 2016, slashing .254/.318/.443 with 24 long-balls in 544 plate appearances. Facing the Rangers, who were bitter rivals by that point, Tulowitzki went deep for his 200th home run while the Jays were in Arlington in mid-May. Two days later, Rougned Odor punched Bautista, raising the temperature of the rivalry even hotter.
The Jays had to get through the Baltimore Orioles in the Wild Card game, doing so thanks to a walk-off home run by Edwin Encarnación. That set up another ALDS matchup against the Rangers. This time, it wasn’t really competitive, as the Jays swept the Rangers in three games, with Tulowitzki hitting a home run in Game 2.
The often-injured Tulowitzki appeared in just 66 games with the Blue Jays in 2017, and didn’t dress for a game in 2018. After just five games with the New York Yankees in 2019, the shortstop announced his retirement.
Tulowitzki was far from the player he once was when the Blue Jays acquired him, but the acquisition alone made the 2015 season special.
Hoffman’s decade away from the Jays
What’s even better is that the Blue Jays didn’t really give up a whole lot. Reyes, the shortstop going to the Rockies, slashed just .259/.291/.368 with three home runs in 208 plate appearances following the trade. He stuck around in the league for three seasons, all three of which were for the Mets, before retiring following the 2018 season.
Castro, who appeared in 13 games for the Jays before the trade, appeared in just five games for the Rockies after the trade, allowing six earned runs in five and one-third innings. After another 19 games for the Rockies in 2016, Castro bounced around the league, spending the 2025 season with the Houston Astros’ organization and appearing in six games for the Chicago White Sox.
Tinoco also most recently pitched in 2025, appearing in 20 games with the Miami Marlins. He spent parts of three seasons with the Rockies, making his debut in 2019. Over 126.2 innings in the big leagues, he had a 5.12 ERA and 4.01 FIP. He missed all of the 2026 season due to an injury.
Hoffman was the main piece going back to the Rockies, as he was the team’s third-best prospect according to MLB Pipeline. Hoffman’s tenure as a Rockie wasn’t great.
Making his big league debut in 2016, the righty posted a 4.88 ERA and 6.27 FIP across 31.1 innings of work. Serving in a bulk role in 2017, Hoffman posted a 5.89 ERA and 4.80 FIP in 99.1 innings pitched, a career-high in innings.
It was the same result for the 2018, 2019, and 2020 seasons before the Rockies traded him to the Cincinnati Reds during the 2020-21 off-season. Out of Coors Field, Hoffman’s numbers improved in 2021, but 2022 was a breakout of sorts. Now 29, Hoffman posted a 3.83 ERA and 4.30 FIP in 44.2 innings of work.
But his real breakout came in 2023 with the Philadelphia Phillies. He signed to a minor league deal, faced Bryce Harper in live at-bats, and the rest is history. The 2023 season saw Hoffman post a 2.41 ERA and 2.57 FIP across 52.1 innings of work. More impressive was his strikeout rate climbing drastically, going from 22.8 percent in 2022 to 33.2 percent in 2023.
Hoffman pitched another season with the Phillies, authoring a 2.17 ERA and 2.52 FIP across 66.1 innings of work, making his first and only All-Star game. During the 2024-25 off-season, Hoffman returned to the Blue Jays on a three-year deal.
Hoffman’s return
Signed to be their closer, Hoffman struggled with consistency issues in 2025. Over 71 outings, Hoffman had a 4.37 ERA and 4.90 FIP in 68 innings of work. His strikeout rate remained high (29.3 K%), but his BB% jumped from 6 percent to 9.4 percent. More concerning was the home runs, giving up 15 in those 68 innings, up from six in 66.1 innings with the Phillies in 2024.
It’s easy to forget just how dominant he was in the 2025 postseason, owning a 1.46 ERA and 2.73 FIP across 12.1 innings of work, with a 37.5 K% and 8.3 BB%. But the one pitch Hoffman will be remembered for came at the worst time. Still ingrained in our mind, Hoffman gave up a game-tying home run in Game 7 of the World Series, and it’s a shame that it’s how his time will be remembered with the Blue Jays.
As a fan, it’s painful to think about even over a year later. I can’t imagine what Hoffman thinks about it. To his credit, he returned and pitched well in 2026, and has even praised Toronto when speaking to free agents, according to Sportsnet’s Ben Nicholson-Smith and Shi Davidi in their recent At The Letters podcast.
There were moments where Hoffman struggled, especially in the first two months of the season. On April 21st, 2026, Hoffman was unable to get the save in a game against the Los Angeles Angels, as manager John Schneider turned to Louis Varland. It took Varland just one pitch to end the game and take over the closer role.
With a four-run lead on May 30th, 2026, Hoffman entered the game and proceeded to give up four earned runs. Had he closed this game out, the Blue Jays would have had a record above .500 for the first time since early April. They didn’t have a record above .500 until early September.
But after that, Hoffman dialed in. Over his next two months, Hoffman pitched to a tune of a 1.21 ERA and 2.34 FIP in 22.1 innings of work, with a 32.6 K% and 8.7 BB%. Hoffman started to excel in a seventh inning role, and raised his trade value significantly.
The 2026 trade
On August 3rd, 2026, the Blue Jays sent Hoffman to the Minnesota Twins for three prospects: John Klein, Dameury Peña, and Dasan Hill.
Hoffman continued to pitch well in his final 20 games, owning a 2.50 ERA and 2.43 FIP across 18 innings of work, with 10 holds and a save. He’s under contract for one more season and underwent surgery early into the off-season.
Of the three prospects the Blue Jays received, Klein is the only one to pitch in the big leagues. Appearing in a game during the final series of the season, the 24-year-old allowed two unearned runs over four innings of work, striking out five and allowing two walks. Still on the 40-man roster, he’ll get some opportunities to pitch for the team in 2027.
Peña is a hit-over-power type of prospect, exactly what the Blue Jays love. In 49 plate appearances following the trade, the infielder joined the High-A Vancouver Canadians and slashed .267/.327/.400 with a home run for a 93 wRC+. As a whole, he slashed .298/.370/.373 with two home runs in 482 total plate appearances in 2026.
Hill was the notable prospect coming back. The left-handed pitcher stands at 6’5”, 165 lbs and posted a 3.86 ERA and 2.62 FIP across 16.1 innings of work with the Canadians following the trade. His command and control were his biggest issues with the Twins, but his BB% plummeted to 9.7 percent in his five games in the Blue Jays organization.
Cynthia Ryley Delaney is a Nation Network writer for Blue Jays Nation, DFOEdmonton, and DFOCalgary. She can be followed on Twitter @CynthiaRDelaney.
Breaking News
- Trade Tree: Looking at both times the Blue Jays traded Jeff Hoffman
- Brendan Cellucci’s strong September set him up to be an option for the Blue Jays’ bullpen in 2027
- Blue Jays podcasters weigh in on the wave of AI sports podcasts
- Yankees reportedly sign Jonathan Loáisiga to two-year deal
- Can the Blue Jays expect more offence from their returning players in 2027?
